
I have three main reasons as to why I oppose Canada’s combatant role in the Afghanistan crisis. My reasons include inhumane practices, environmental impacts and the societal desire to withdraw. Although the Canadian army does not torture the captured Taliban, the detainees are transferred to Afghan authorities who participate in torture. As stated by the globe and mail, “The Harper government knew from its own officials that prisoners held by Afghan security forces faced the possibility of torture, abuse and extrajudicial killing” (Koring, 2007). Examples of torture that the detainees endure are beatings with bricks, deprivation of sleep, and electric shocks (Canada out of Afghanistan, 2008). These practices are inhumane and void of morals. Whether these detainees are criminals or not, they deserve the right to fair trail with a lawyer. Barbaric torture is not the solution, and as Canadians we should advocate civilized methods that preserve human rights. If we deal with criminals in our country in a modern and humane manner why should we contribute to degrading inhumane practices elsewhere?
The deployment of radioactive weaponry used by NATO, such as the depleted uranium munitions, leads to grave consequences for the local environment and it is also responsible for the birth defects. In 2001, approximately 800-1000 tons of depleted uranium had been used (Canada out of Afghanistan, 2008). The image above demonstrates not only the irreversible conditions of this child, but the thousands of innocent lives who currently are and will continue to suffer.
As a Canadian, I agree with the majority of Canadians who do not view the Afghan conflict as an issue central to our national security. Approximately 47% of Canadians want our troops to be withdrawn from Afghanistan. Although Al-Qaeda has never attacked Canada, the issue of our nation fighting alongside the U.S. causes Canadians to worry that the risk of being attacked will increase (Power, 2008). I understand their view on the issue; however it is also necessary that we do aid the crisis in Afghanistan without engaging into combat. I am not an expert in this subject matter, but through donations and relief in the form of food and basic necessities we should alleviate the detrimental conditions without causing further harm to individuals and the environment.
.